1. Quenching Cracks: Higher Temperature Isn't Harder
Cr12MoV is a high-carbon, high-chromium ledeburitic steel with a wide quenching temperature range, but performance varies dramatically across that range. Many chase high hardness by pushing quenching temperature above 1050°C, resulting in coarse grains, excessive retained austenite, and extremely high internal stress—cracking is just a matter of time.
A more sensible approach: choose quenching temperature based on application. For high-wear cold stamping dies, 1030-1050°C works; for cold heading dies needing toughness, 980-1020°C is safer. After quenching, temper immediately, and temper twice: first at 200-250°C to relieve quenching stress, second adjusted to your hardness target. Insufficient tempering means wire EDM will crack it later.

2. Wire EDM Cracks: Insufficient Tempering Is the Main Cause
Cr12MoV molds cracking during wire EDM is a classic industry headache. The root cause is usually not wire EDM itself, but insufficient tempering after quenching—retained austenite transforms to martensite during cutting, expands in volume, and tears the mold apart.
Three preventive measures: first, temper thoroughly after quenching to transform as much retained austenite as possible; second, add a stress-relief temper before wire EDM; third, use multi-pass cutting instead of one deep cut, giving stress time to release. For complex shapes with uneven wall thickness, rough machine and stress-relieve before final wire cutting.
| Comparison Items | Cr12MoV Mold Steel | Cr12 Mold Steel |
| Hardness (Quenched) | 58-62 HRC | 58-62 HRC |
| Hardenability | Good | Fair |
| Toughness | Moderate | Poor |
| Carbide Segregation | Moderate | Severe |
| Wire EDM Cracking Risk | Lower (with proper tempering) | Higher |
| Main Use | Cold stamping, cold heading, drawing dies | Simple cold stamping dies |
As shown above, Cr12MoV improves on Cr12 mainly in hardenability and toughness, and its carbide segregation is less severe—which directly reduces wire EDM cracking risk when tempering is done properly. Cr12 is cheaper but more prone to cracking and chipping. If your cold work mold involves complex shapes, impact loads, or wire EDM, Cr12MoV is the safer choice; just don't skip the double tempering.
3. Balancing Wear Resistance and Toughness: Don't Fixate on Hardness
Cr12MoV's wear resistance is unquestionable, but toughness is its weak spot. Many mold failures aren't wear failures—they're chipping and fracture. If you're making cold heading dies or punches under impact load, chasing HRC 60+ hardness actually invites premature chipping.
Consider adjusting the heat treatment: lower the quenching temperature slightly, raise the tempering temperature, and control hardness at HRC 58-60 in exchange for better toughness. Also, Cr12MoV has severe eutectic carbide segregation—whether forging and homogenizing annealing are done well directly determines mold life. If the raw material has coarse, unevenly distributed carbides, no heat treatment can save it.
In one sentence: 80% of Cr12MoV cracking problems come from heat treatment and tempering, 20% from the material itself. Choose the right quenching temperature, temper thoroughly, and don't rush wire EDM—then it will work reliably in your cold work molds.
For more information about our solutions and services, please contact us.
FAQ
Q1: What is the suitable quenching temperature for Cr12MoV mold steel?
A: Typically 980-1050°C, adjusted by application. High-wear cold stamping dies: 1030-1050°C; cold heading dies needing toughness: 980-1020°C.
Q2: Why does Cr12MoV crack during wire EDM?
A: Mainly due to insufficient tempering after quenching—retained austenite transforms to martensite during cutting, expanding and causing cracks. Temper thoroughly and use multi-pass cutting.
Q3: What is the difference between Cr12MoV and Cr12?
A: Cr12MoV adds molybdenum and vanadium to Cr12, improving hardenability, toughness, and wear resistance, with relatively reduced carbide segregation. It is now the more commonly used cold work mold steel.
Q4: What hardness is suitable for Cr12MoV mold steel?
A: Generally HRC 58-62 for cold stamping dies; HRC 58-60 for cold heading dies under impact. Don't blindly chase excessive hardness.